News & Media
Mr. Straus is active in many charitable and philanthropic endeavors.
Posted on: February 2, 2017
Author: Daniel E. Straus
As talk swirls about repealing and replacing Obamacare, President Trump must train his focus on the fundamental error of the ACA, which is the shift in patient care decision-making away from frontline physicians and toward hospitals and insurance companies. Health insurance for everyone is important; however if it comes at the expense of providing quality healthcare to everyone, it is at best a pyrrhic victory. Hospitals are the most expensive and many times inefficient venue for the delivery of care and have contributed to rising costs while also failing to improve the quality of patient care.
The root of the problem lies in the Obama administration’s misplaced trust in “accountable care organizations” (ACO)—the integrated care organizations envisioned by the ACA to contract with the Federal government to reduce Medicare costs. For example, the current data from the Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services (CMS) indicates that the ACA’s Pioneer ACO did indeed reduce Medicare costs—by approximately $700 million in 2014—but required a whopping expenditure of over $1 billion to generate those savings. After accounting for the 50 percent share of savings distributed to the ACOs by CMS, those entities lost more than $500 million.
Dr. Robert Kocher, a special assistant to President Obama, is correct in stating that the ACOs failed in their objectives because of the faulty assumption that hospitals and large medical systems were necessary ACO partners due to financing and infrastructure needs. Rather than help the ACOs achieve greater savings, the early data paints a picture suggesting that ACOs affiliated with large hospitals and academic medical centers performed worse than ACOs that were operated by smaller physician groups without substantial participation by hospital providers.